A few weeks ago I cleft grafted 103 sour orange rootstocks with sweet oranges, mandarins and tangelo scions. I am pleased that 92 of the 103 grafts were successful (my highest success rate so far), but I wanted to learn why 11 grafts failed.
Today I unwrapped them, and here's what I found:
On the graft below, I think the scion was a little too thin. I should have watched more carefully and put it on a thinner rootstock.
This rootstock was not straight, and when I cut into it from the top, the cut followed the uneven grain so cambial contact was limited. I should have cut the rootstock where it was straight.
Here's another one where the scion appeared to be too small:
The bottom of this scion should have been cut thinner. It was forcing the two sides of the rootstock apart instead of clamping the scion in place. The rootstock cut was also not centered properly.
This one is interesting, because the bottom of the scion appears to have some life in it. I can't figure this one out.
One thing I learned from this: The scion should always be
slightly thicker than the rootstock. This allows better contact between cambiam layers. If they are the same size, and both scion and rootstock are cut down their middle, the very bottom of the scion is the only place that can make cambial contact. Someone on a forum (either this one or the Citrus Growers) suggested the scion should be thicker, but I haven't read it in any of my books discussing cleft grafts. This drawing I made to clarify the concept. When the scion is slightly thicker, cambial contact should be achieved near the two areas circled.
I also had either a compatability problem or a bad scion stick because only one out of 5 Orlando Tangelo was successful (vs. 90+% on the others)
Thank you for allowing me to share this with you, and for reading this far. I'd appreciate any comments or suggestions relating to cleft or veneer grafting.
John