Didn't think this warranted another thread so I'll just add to this thread: I've ordered two custom boxes from Squam and Tropical Acres. I've lived in the northeast all my life (currently CT but DC and NYC in the past) and have only had access to the following mangoes - Ataulfo, Kent, Keitt, and Tommy Atkins. Kent is the only one I eat that I consistently enjoy...Ataulfo is almost always overripe when I see them at Costco. Hope you all know how good you have it when it comes to mangoes down there! I have now tried: PPK, NDM #4, Duncan, Dupuis Saigon, Cogshall, Edward. PPK was also my favorite, but I loved Dupuis. The NDM was overripe and that was entirely my fault, as I'm still getting a feel for judging the ripeness. I have another I'm going to try as well. The Cogshall had a very pronounced peach note, which was wonderful, as the peaches around here that aren't from an orchard are terrible! The ordering process is smooth and I have a box at my door within 2-3 days, all arriving in good condition.
I think I'll be doing another box soon, not sure which ones to try as there seems to be less information on the others. Decisions, decisions.