Malhar, yes I have the Red Himalayan from Brad but I also want to purchase the one from Marta, DMOR9, since her photos of the Himalayan shows different pattern on the leaves, has some lobes, Brad's and my grafted ones do not have that type of leaf even though the fruit is similar red, skinny, long (read above posts). I always like to have multiple source until I know the fruits and tree grows as described.