Yeah, I tried homemade cloth bags and they dry out too fast. Gave up on that and used the cloth to line the bottom of the rootmaker.
Rootmaker 2 is cheaper if you get it somewhere like alibaba. $3-4 a foot here is kinda expensive for the roll, but I'm still on that roll now.
Knlim000, you should get a 3 gal rootmaker and whatever others you want to use for evaluation. Then you'll know what its capabilities are so you can compare it with your home made solutions. It's hard to design a similar or better/similar device if you don't have a good feel of how the existing one performs.