I am confused by this thread, because going back to the beginning it seems that it was perhaps merged with a different one about Noni. I don't get why, because they are two totally different plants. But, on the subject of Noni, it seemed worth it to mention that Noni are quite easy to grow here, and my plant is now much larger and has produced 8 or 9 fruit this year (more seem to be showing up every week or two, so I don't know how many it will end with). One fell off early, and since I never got to try last year's fruit because it disappeared (squirrels? iguanas?) before it ripened, I ate this one raw even while it was green and small. It was my first Noni ever. WOW, I really enjoyed it! It did not have any smell, and was actually crunchy and delicious as a vegetable! Who knew?
So, I bagged all the rest to be sure they don't get stolen, and if they fall early I can eat them unrripe. So far though, one in particular really seems to be growing and may hold on, and the others are still small but hanging in there. I'm not going to pick any off early to eat, since I've still never had a fully grown ripe one, but if any more fall, I am very much looking forward to eating them raw. Hard to describe the taste. But crunchy/crispy like a raw broccoli stalk, but much more mild tasting. No odor. And at the size I ate it, no noticeable seeds either. I assume it has many of the properties of the fully grown ripe fruit, if not all of them. So if one enjoys vegetables, I would not rule out growing Noni purely based on its stinky reputation for ripe fruit, assuming you have a climate in which a Noni would do well. Ashitaba/Angelica Keiske may be another story, since I have had no luck with that so far whatsoever. Note also that young leaves of Noni are reported to be edible, as well as medicinal. I have not bothered to experiment with this too much yet, but have tasted pieces here and there.