Cac Hoa Loc from Toptrop, or fake?

[sapote]

I bought this special Vietnamese mango – at higher price --  from Toptrop a few years ago. This year it had a few fruits, and based on the look it is not Cac Hoa Loc as sold but rather Mahachanok to me. So far I have two incidents that they seem to have mis-labeling the trees: wrong Edward and Cac Hoa Loc. I hate when this happened because we spent lots of effort and times, especially outside of idea tropical climate area, to nurture the trees and then ended up with something else.

I could be wrong but this pic shows it is Maha and not the yellow Cac Hoa Loc. Now I have two Maha trees.

[Squam256]

Place has an unbelievable mis-label rate.

Fruit in the photo is a Maha, definitely NOT Hoa Loc.

[simon_grow]

Agreed, definitely not CAC/COC

Simon

[Greenlizard]

You're not wrong.  I've had Mahachanok in Thailand, and Cat Hoa Loc in Vietnam.  I agree with the above posts.  The trees look different too.

[Tropicdude]

Sure looks like a Maha to me.

[dungnguyen]

This is not Vietnamese mango 'Cat Hoa Loc' friend.
And the correct name is Cat Hoa Loc, not Cac Hoa Loc.
Here is the pictures for Cat Hoa Loc:

Still green on the tree



When it ripens

[Vernmented]

So is Cac/Coc the same as Cat Hoa Loc?

[Squam256]

So is Cac/Coc the same as Cat Hoa Loc?

No, different mangos.