1
The Internet's Finest Tropical Fruit Discussion Forum!
"All discussion content within the forum reflects the views of the individual participants and does not necessarily represent the views held by the Tropical Fruit Forum as an organization."
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Wgphil- since you are relatively close to me, what do you do to keep your mangos warm? I have a graham in a pot right now and I am considering putting it into the ground as it is almost too big to move at this point. I was thinking come winter to mound mulch up the trunk and get natural warmth that way. Throw on a blanket and my guess is that would be enough with the mild winters we have been having.I have some unwanted trees growing on my property. I've been planting my mangos on the south side of these. Eventually I'll cut them down once my mangos have grown enough. I had some success last winter planting them like this. If you have any plant that you want to remove someday you can try this.
How do you kno that nature hasn't been selecting for 100s of years already? It maybe a long shot but it's not an impossible dream.If a person planted 100 Mango seeds, is it possible that some of the seedling trees would be more cold tolerant and/or disease resistant than others?
Very unlikely....where are the lab results? Natural selection takes a long time you are not going to get results in 20 years with a small batch of seedlings
What do you think?
Personally i have been surprised so many times by something completly unexpected, that i have learn to avoid telling something is completly impossible. Also, i don't think that mangoes have ever been breed for frost resistance (correct me if i'm wrong). So i put everything in the realm of the possibilities. My concerns are just two fold;
1) Did the mango in the USA have a genetical base wide enough to have some frost tolerance genes in them? I'm assuming they have been breed using mainly DNA from the USA.
2) What does means 20F? Whas the temperature measured for the city, ot the temperature registered at the canopy? Was the temperature at ground level? How long it lasted? For example, I have a small seedling of Gomera-3. If i put it in the freezer at 0F for 15 seconds it won't get any damage. Can we say that it did survive 0F? The most important thing when we speak about killing temperatures for any plant isn't the temperature by itself but also how it was experienced by the plant.
Just my two cents. That said, i respect the work of anyone involved in breeding even more because it's something i probably wouldn't be able to do.
[/quote
Excellent on all points !!!
I am doing just that. I have 2-yr seedlings of Coconut Cream, Lemon Zest, and Fruit Punch. My plan is to graft half of these seedling branches with true parent wood and leave rest of the half to become adult and fruit at some point. this way if in 5 plus years I get crappy fruit, I wouldn't have wasted my time as I would have the tree also hold true parents that also grew in 5-years. Its worth every bit to try seedlings to fruit. this is the only way to get new top tier varieties slowly.That's a smart way to do it. I have 3 trees from seed and I was planing on top working them if they ever produce bad fruit. If anyone ever gets a truly cold tolerant tree no matter how bad it tasted that would be a special tree.
I dont think people realize the process needed when experimenting with seeds. Its not just plant a seed, let it fruit in a few years and away we go. The plant will need to be monitored for many years for the following: fruit quality, tree characteristics such as cold tolerance, disease resistance, growth habit, etc. These are all things that can, and usually do, change from year to year while the tree is in a juvenile/devellopment stage. You will then need to see how it reacts when grafted, and even grown in different locations. This process can easily take upwards of ten or more years. This is not usually accomplished by planting one seed either.That's is an important point Rob. Anyone thinking of doing this has to know that failure is the most likely result. That being said I would encourage anyone that has a spot to try growing some fruit from seed. Every effort is worth a shot. Zills approach is one way to develop new things and obviously worked extremely well. If thousands of home owners each planted one seed that's another way. BTW 30 years ago my father planted 1000 mango trees from seed on the same property I'm working with these days. The same year every last seedling was killed by frost. Needless to say he gave up on fruit and starred raising livestock. So anyway... I'm not unaware of the risk. On the contrary I'm extremely concerned about if.
Those who are planting seeds especially of mono varieties (for example the Indian varieties), keep in mind you may invest years, space, cost to find out you have a fibrous piece of crap that will need to be cut down. This experimenting is usually done by people who invest their life into it and have plenty of space.
Look, I am all for people who have the time and space to take this on but most have no idea what they are getting into. Gary Zill did not just throw out some seeds like Jack and the Beanstalk and get these top varieties in a few years. He invested many many years and lots of time, space and money to get to where things are. There is a reason he is not doing it again.
Just my 2 pennies on the subject...
To OCchris: you need to relax man. You come too late, miss a bunch of nonsensical later edited stuff that btw included oral sex joke by the poster. I actually do have a heart, and it pains when somebody comes and trashes overall quality of the forum.DrainoLover you must be an very angry person. Someone hurt you really bad didn't they? Listen pal it's ok you'll be alright it may just take a while.
He still never posted where his trees are planted. Climate zone, city, state? Mighty the first guy ever here to ask for cold protection advice while keeping his location a secret. Does that makes any sense to you?
I met with Miss Cleo yesterday and you would not believe what she said. Anyone care to take a guess?