I know this has been done to death and YES, I've spent hours and hours of my life searching the forum for everyone's mango opinions. But often you mango experts are talking amongst yourselves under the correct assumption that you've all tasted all the varieties in question and can make comparisons based on that common knowledge. So I'm posing the question as someone who has tried almost no mangoes, but I know some things I like/ don't like and some preferences I have for the trees. So here goes:
I'd like to have 5 mangoes. I hate Hadens, which is the #1 grafted mango here. I hate them because they're like dental floss with an insipid, watery mango flavor. Yuck. There are 2 other mangoes here - small yellow ones many of which are probably seedlings, with varying levels of fiber. If they're not too fibrous, I can enjoy them because they have a stronger flavor with a resiny kick. Not terrible. The other grafted mango here is Irwin. I've had only one of those - they're not at all common - but it was quite good. Compared to a Haden, it was spectacular. I've scoured the forum for info on Irwin and have seen that it's no where near top tier, but the one I had didn't have internal breakdown or any other nastiness, so I guess I got lucky. (I'm considering getting an Irwin tree just because it's the one decent mango available here. But it doesn't count towards my 5.)
So I hate Hadens, I like some resin flavor. I don't really want heavy citrus flavors in my mango because I prefer to get my citrus flavors from citrus (for that I've ruled out LZ). I like intense flavors but not just straight sugar bombs (Rob's description of Cotton Candy put me off). I hate jelly seed, and while creamy sounds nice, mushy definitely does not. We do have anthracnose around here so resistance is important - we're not going to spray. Not being an overly giant tree would be great too. My plan is to bring down 2 already grafted trees and get scions for the other 3 to graft - one day I'll have to get a mango graft to take!
I've got 4 on my list so far: Pickering (for size, precocity, disease resistance, consistent production and good quality fruit, though I know many sneer at the Pickering, I've also seen quite a few positive reviews), Sweet Tart, Maha, and Kesar. I'm open to debate any of those, but they got on my list from the extensive forum searching that I've done so far - those 4 seem to consistently stand out positively in ways that appeal to me.
If you were me, what 5 would you choose? And which 2 would you buy already grafted, while grafting the other 3? Remember, I've never tasted the top tiers, so no fair using them as reference points! (also no fair suggesting varieties I could only get if I lived in FL and knew the secret handshake!
)
Thanks everyone!