WTB (or Trade): Genoa Loquat or Tanaka or China Doll

[sc4001992]

I'm looking to buy or trade for the following loquat:

1) Genoa loquat, originated by John Panzarella.
2) Tanaka
3) China Doll

If you have a few scion cuttings available please send me a PM.

I can trade for any other loquat variety you might be looking for, let me know which one. Also can trade for mulberry (Black Pakistan, White Pakistan, Shangri La, Tice, Thai Dwarf, Red Himalayan).

Send me a PM if you have this tree.

Thanks, Kaz

[sc4001992]

bump, did not get any feedback on this request.

If you have any of the above, I can buy or trade with one from my collection of 62 varieties.
For this trade, I will cut some peluche to make this trade.

[sc4001992]

I will cut my peluche if someone has any of the 3 above for trade.

[sc4001992]

Any Update?

Offer still stands for trade.

[sc4001992]

FYI, I do have all three now, but always looking for a second source of my loquats.
Sorry, none of my grafts are large enough to take cuttings to share at this time.

If anyone has these louqats and had fruits, I would be interested in hearing your comments on the taste of these three varieties. I noticed that the grow habit of the Tanaka seems to be the slowest so far (2yr old graft) and it doesn't have any flowers/fruits forming yet. China Doll is a strong grower.

[Bush2Beach]

China Doll is another Jim Neitzel variety?

[sc4001992]

Yes, I have now both the China White and China Doll is from Jim Neitzel collection.

I heard from a few people that have tasted both different results of which one they think tastes better. My China White grafts are larger now and have many fruits now so at least I will be able to compare some fruits this summer.

Not sure why there are not that many people with China Doll, but when my grafts (just recent grafted) grow more by next year, if you're interested Jonah send me a PM. I'm not planning to sell/trade this one for a while to the forum. I'm also looking forward to tasting a new an Italian variety (Imperiale) that is one of the best there, it has large fruits, maybe a little larger than my Big Jim. I should be able to taste the fruit this summer and will post my taste results.

[Bush2Beach]

Cool, thank you.
In the next year or two we can put all Big Jim’s cultivars side by side and do a comparison & tasting.
I have Jazzy and Big White holding fruit this year .
I’ll send you a PM and see if I can get you something good your mother tree doesn’t have yet.

[sc4001992]

Sounds good.

I also have some fruits of the Jazzy, and Jim's Big White. Last year I had the wrong variety (mix up) so my Big Jim's White was not the true one, same with Jazzy, it was also mixed up. This year I should have the correct Jazzy fruit, still not sure if the Big Jim's White that's fruiting is the correct one.