Phil, yes your correct, Sour Orange is not as cold hardy as Flying Dragon or other trifoliates. However, it is more cold hardy than many other rootstocks. I see the University of Florida list Sour orange as a "G" for freezes. "G" stands for good. All the trees I purchased from you were on FD, and all are doing good. My in ground Cara Cara is on FD, and it is now 11-ft. tall and 11-ft. wide. About 10+ years old. I don't remember exactly when it was planted.
Here 500 miles north of the citrus belt anything but trifoliate and FD are not cold hardy.
There are many, many seville orange trees growing around here because the graft got frozen
away. Lots of trees used to come from the Valley which uses sour orange exclusively. Now the local
growers switched from trifoliate to citrange. I take advantage use sevilles for marmalade as someone I know usually
has bushels of inedible seville fruit without a use.
The predominant root stock now is carrizo citrange not because it is cold hardy
but because it grows a bigger tree in one year than trifoliate. Big sells. When a tree freezes the average homeowner has
no explanation for why but it is likely the root stock not being cold tolerant.
My experience with swingle is that the tree grows 4x as fast as one on flying dragon. I've been growing trees on FD since 2000 but
would have got a lot more fruit if on swingle. Since 2000 there hasn't been any citrus killing
freezes so choice of root stock hasn't been very important. I now prefer swingle and know a guy with a large bearing swingle tree.
In this year's 19F my one tree on swingle had bark cracking damage while the one on sour orange killed the graft.