Tropical Fruit Forum - International Tropical Fruit Growers



Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - DurianLover

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 50
1
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: Artocarpus ID Please
« on: April 05, 2018, 08:43:44 PM »
There is no a. hirsutus in Thailand, but they do have a. rigidus as a native tree.  It's a closer photo much, just not polinated very well perhaps.

2
Quote from: ajeshcool47 link=topic=27681
[url=https://postimg.org/image/zadg58t23/
[/url]

Looks like this picture taken 8 meters in the air. You have good climbing skills  ;D

3
These are what happened to my Marang seedling:






Any idea what could cause this? I have them under grow light occasionally get late afternoon sun from window. These were in the garage around 75-80F in South Florida winter (not humid). The photos were taken in December, they all are dead now.


I read this all the time: " I gave them warmth, humidity, artificial light and they still died". First of of all most trees aren't your tomato plants. They have far more adcanced features how they able to sense and interact with surrounding environment. Many cool studies and experiments in this field. They have grearter need for real sunlight rather than tomato for example. Artificial light probably has one type of infra-red out of three, maybe few other wavelengths. There is a whole spectrum of ligh missing or gets filtered by a glass.
Another example, I could probably thrive and survive for a while in underground bunker with plastic food and a tanning bed to compensate sun. But eventually I will start to deteriorate
longing for real sun on my face and feeling of wind in my hair like I'm genetically accustomed. 

4
This marang tree as been negelected and unprotected for the last 4 years. Every once in a while, I pick it up after it has fallen on its side.  It got down to 37F here this winter.



At this speed your great grandchildren will be able to enjoy fruits of your labor  :P

5
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: grow dabai in container and pot
« on: March 11, 2018, 12:11:09 AM »
The problem with all those bonsai, pruning, and grafting ideas that this particular species grows in usual fashion like a palm. My tree looks like a tall branchless palm now. All the growth happens from tip of the tree, any branches near the top fall off quickly as the tree grows.  I have strong suspicion if you cut the top, the tree will likely die. But never done such experiment. There is just one picture on the internet of young trees, you can sort get an idea how challenging pruning or topworking is going to be. This tree simply want to grow like a palm during first several years.
Regarding 4 years from seeds, these particular info comes from Malaysian publication describing growth of grafted cultivars. Looks like it has been later copy and pasted all over the internet as a fact. But in reality people attempting to grow this species report much longer time. This particular Sarawak native women says it took 10 years for the first flowers to appear.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXWn_Jzan3E





6
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: grow dabai in container and pot
« on: March 09, 2018, 02:16:17 AM »
My 2 year old baby in 2016, now 1.5 years later it's almost twice as tall. Yet it is still 2-3 years from fruiting ( if I win sex selection lottery).  Considering what you see, you'll have to have magician's skill to fruit it in a pot of any size.



7
Part two of the update. Marangs. This is most promising species. Nearly all marangs I got made them bushy with lost of low spreading branches and no clear leader.  After seeing how well it reacts to size control, I think it's borderline sinful act just to plant and do nothing about size control  :) .

This is the only tree from from the first post.  Reuploading first pic to follow progress. The earlier pic is after second toping at 9 feet and the tree now.





Marang nr. 2. Topped higher than I usually do at around 7 feet and additional toppings of the leaders.



Marang nr. 3.  Topped at maybe 4 feet, than additional toppings of 3 leaders, now about 10 feet tall.




8
Hi Rytis,
A. hirsutus grow like this only. You can't find lower branches on large trees, because Wild jacks are grown mainly for timber in Kerala. Moreover, lower branches dies off from the tree as the tree grows. BTB, this species is very fast growing.
Could you please tell something about growth rate of A. hirsutus? Some of the forum members are arguing that the species is slow growing.

That's too bad about lower branches dying off eventually, but again I don't think anybody in India is pruning so much and so early like I do. Some of the low branches are very sturdy. I just don't don't see how they will die off eventually. I have another hirsutus, which I was pruning even more aggressively and lower branches are relatively very strong and thick compared to the rest of the tree.  I guess time will tell how it works out eventually.
Yes A. hirsutus is super fast growing. My top 3 fastest trees. If I would not have been pruning it would have been much taller.

9
Any updates to the trees described in this post?


Some updates on artocarpus pruning techniques.  This is my last post. I'm done with pruning and topping. Trees are too big now to control them.

My method is pretty simple.  Cut the leader at about 5-6 feet. One usually get's leader to split into 2 or 3 branches, let them grow 3-4 feet and top all the leaders again. That's about it. Very simple. Works for nearly all artocarpus species. This technique is especially awesome on marang.

First of all on which species my method does not work. That would be chempedak and jackfruit. Looks like for these two are very much dependant on a variety, particular seedling, whether grafted or not, etc.  However what does really work well for chempedak size control is budding ( not grafting) on jackfruit. Those trees don't even look like trees. They grow like bushes. Here is a pic of example:



Pedalai. This tree was topped countless times.  I was determined to tame this giant.  I think all the topping let to the sprout and growth of the second trunk, which also has been topped. I even got third trunk to sprout, you can see. But I got greedy, wanted to split super low, and the tree simple abandoned that brach. Despite all efforts tree has intimidating size. I think most fruits will be unreachable anyway if it ever fruits.



Artocarpus hirsutus.  This tree was topped maybe 3 times. Also the side leaders got haircuts during second on third time. I only seen big trees, never seen young trees, so not sure if my method worked on this species or not. Maybe young seedlings looks naturally this way?  Mature trees if seen hardly have any low branches.  Can somebody from Kerala comment on a photo? Vipin?



Unidentified artocarpus. Since we here maybe somebody can ID? I'm pretty sure it's keledang. Usually don't plant without id, but this one planted anyway. If this is indeed keledang than it's great looking bushy tree without clear central leader using technique described above. I've seen mature tree in rainforest environment and fruits are basically unreachable. 



I'll update on  marangs later, when have more time.


10
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: Can cherimoya grow in Vietnam?
« on: September 21, 2017, 10:36:20 PM »
I think Mikey is waiting for growers in tropical areas to tell him what happens if there's no chill hours. Will it die or just not set fruit.

There are cherimoyas growing nicely in Singapore botanical gardens for decades. It is as tropical as it gets at sea level, 100 km from equator. But it does not mean anything because they never fruit.

11
Edit. Not available anymore

This is wholesale offer only.  Have remaining seeds, don't have time for small orders or USDA paperwork. Make reasonable offer and take everything. EMS only. 18 Musang King seeds and 7 "Ice Cream" also called "Kuching Tidur", translates sleeping cat.  Legitimate five star variety.  Apparently even Lindsey never came across this one. See comments sections:

http://www.yearofthedurian.com/2016/07/black-thorn-durian-668.html
http://www.opensnap.com/en/indonesia-other/p-kucing-tidur-durian-p201437906











12
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: Can cherimoya grow in Vietnam?
« on: September 16, 2017, 05:06:13 AM »
Yes, for sure. But you need higher elevations. Starting points somewhere 600-700 meters  in tropics far from equator and roughly 1200 meters close to equator like Southern Vietnam. I've been having local Sri Lankan cherimoyas this entire past week even though we are clearly deep in tropics. Main production areas here at 2000 meters. Roughly 6000 feet elevation.

13
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: pocket knife tough enough for durian
« on: September 02, 2017, 04:45:03 PM »
In Malaysia all durian sellers use butcher style knifes, something like picture below. These knifes makes easy to split durian rinds once knife inserted into fruit. There are foldable versions of this style.


14
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: Rambutan vs. Pulisan
« on: September 02, 2017, 04:32:03 PM »
http://rfcarchives.org.au/Next/CaringForTrees/MinTemps3-88.htm
The Australian experience with minimum tolerable temperatures is listed in the link. Obviously species like breadfruit can survive lower temps briefly.

That's a handy reference chart. Ofcourse a species being able to survive a certain temperature does not necessarily mean it will fruit if consistently exposed to such temperatures.


Wait a minute, mangosteen +3?? I thought the plant can't handle less than 10ºC.

Can handle +3C for very short period of time. Can't handle 10C for any extended period of time.


Funny, that's my entire point. I'll repeat the same thing again. It absolutely doesn't matter what what type of microclimate Jose is in. He still has to go through very long and very cool Mediterranean winters.  People focusing only at kill temperatures and winter minimum at location. According this website almost all winter night time temps hovering in 40s and daytime often struggles to reach 60. https://en.aurigacrown.com/blog/marbella-climate/.  Even SoCal is much more tropical in winter. Rambutan not ok to try in SoCal, but ok in Spain? Where is the logic? Jose maybe technically zone 11 and temps never drop below 40, but his location will never rival possibilities for tropicals offered in zone 10 of S.FL.   Until people start to understand detrimental effects of prolonged and persistent cool temps on many sensitive tropicals species we can't have rational conversation here.

15
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: Rambutan vs. Pulisan
« on: August 31, 2017, 06:39:01 PM »

The pulusan though is a real tropical, right? I mean, in a subtropical climate we just have one option to pick from these 3 species: lychee. Or it would be a realistic bet to expect a crop from pulusan or rambutan trees in a 11a or colder region?

Yes pulasan is an ultra tropical. The rambutan is also tropical, but it seems more widely adapted than pulasan. So you would probably be able to grow it and fruit if you give it some special protection in winter. Lychee is subtropical, so should be easy for your area.


There were only one or two successful rambutan fruitings in S. FL after enormous efforts to keep them alive, even though S. FL has nearly everything going for it: borderline tropical climate, sufficient humidity etc.  Southern Spain is much cooler and drier, no matter what microclimate Jose is in. It's subtropical/ mediterranean climate.  Rambutan maybe alive for a while but will be absolutely miserable. I feel sorry when people given false hope. There is good reason 2-3 years on they never update on their little pet projects.

No, Southern Florida does not have everything going for it for growing rambutans. The problem with Florida and rambutans is not the temperatures, but the soil. Rambutans will not grow in alkaline soils, and a lot of southern Florida is limestone. The people that fruited them trucked in soil from elsewhere. Also S. Florida gets occasional arctic blasts. Does Southern Spain also experience these? Anyway, note that i said he would need to protect them in winter. Humidity can be easily controlled by adding overhead misters.


http://tropicalfruitforum.com/index.php?topic=1249.0

I know about the soil. It's not just occasional cold blast it's persistent temps in 50's or 60's for days or even weeks in winter combined with arctic blast, which is far more stressful than occasional overnight dips in S. FL.  Southern Spain more or less = SoCal. Let somebody grow rambutan in the best of SoCal microclimate even with misters, and let's see how far that goes. This may sound new agey but seems like some species sense being on artificial life support and not happy about it at all, even though technically everything is provided.  There is quite a bit of scientific research into subject.

16
Tropical Fruit Discussion / Re: Rambutan vs. Pulisan
« on: August 31, 2017, 05:43:51 PM »

The pulusan though is a real tropical, right? I mean, in a subtropical climate we just have one option to pick from these 3 species: lychee. Or it would be a realistic bet to expect a crop from pulusan or rambutan trees in a 11a or colder region?
Yes pulasan is an ultra tropical. The rambutan is also tropical, but it seems more widely adapted than pulasan. So you would probably be able to grow it and fruit if you give it some special protection in winter. Lychee is subtropical, so should be easy for your area.

There were only one or two successful rambutan fruitings in S. FL after enormous efforts to keep them alive, even though S. FL has nearly everything going for it: borderline tropical climate, sufficient humidity etc.  Southern Spain is much cooler and drier, no matter what microclimate Jose is in. It's subtropical/ mediterranean climate.  Rambutan maybe alive for a while but will be absolutely miserable. I feel sorry when people given false hope. There is good reason 2-3 years on they never update on their little pet projects.

17
Those were Mexican imports by the truckload hence near wholesale price. Don't worry you have better quality in FL from homegrown garden. Quality, over quantity.

18
I'm assuming I won't be getting any fruit until I see female flowers appearing and cross-pollinating with male flowers.  So however many more years that may be, what happens in the meantime to the male flowers?  Excuse my ignorance, but an internet search didn't provide any clues.  How big do they grow?  Do they eventually die?

And for the poster who asked, I'm about 6-8 miles inland from the coast in Los Angeles.  It gets as cold as about 60 degrees at night in the summer and down to 50 in the winter.

It's not necessarily years. Usually female will appear about a year after male flowers. But it could longer in a cool SoCal. Although you are in a pretty sweet spot. Away from cool coastal areas and not too far inland for a tree to be stressed by cold.
Meanwhile if you are craving freh jackfruit, they have piles of it in a Little Saigon. Few months ago I purchased a whole 23 pounder for $13 only.

19
Credit this quote to a Sleepdoc that goes something like this: "Female flowers will appear and fruits will mature when trunk is about soda can thickness" That has been my experience too. Your tree is not there yet.

20
Not super fresh overripe Pulasan + Photoshop =$10 per seed? :)
Where are you from?
I just made a photo today, no photoshop, just cell phone camera and pulasan.
Okay, not so black...  :)


Ali is an honest guy. That's not a photoshop,
https://www.rarepalmseeds.com/pix/NepTru.shtml

"The Pulasan is an incredibly variable species with unique landraces all over its extensive range"

21
That looks like nice quality and size. I have few trees already, at this time just looking for good genetics. Can you tell about age of the tree, productivy, how old was the tree when started producing first?

22
Short of unrelated questions in this thread. I sacrificed one of my Orange Sherbet to graft Sweet Tart on top. Didn't have rootstock around. Is there any way to extract propogatable material from the rootstock? As much as I like ST,  the better mango might be under.


You need to induce some branches to grow out at the root stock level. To induce you have to nick through the bark and cambium layers the right way and just a small amount. Hopefully someone can give you better details and personal experience.

https://www.bing.com/search?q=mango%20tree%20induce%20branching&qs=n&form=QBRE&sp=-1&pq=mango%20tree%20induce%20branching&sc=0-27&sk=&cvid=94AC71068C174201BFE29306E57A74C0

http://tinyurl.com/yc25kvl4


and check youtube for notching fruit trees and mango trees
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LXdexMgFobA

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kq08NuQ_bfI


Thank you Mr. Zands. Learned something new. Notching to promote a branch is a brand new concept to me.

23
I got a question for you guys. Given that shipping from USA can take up to 3 weeks and that Customs here is becoming more a more careful with vegetal stuff because of diseases like Xilella, purchasing scions is kind of a very risky bet for us. I've been said by another grower from Europe that rate of taking for imported scions from America is really low because of that. So I'm thinking now of another strategy to do it: Would be a safer, more successful way to get these new varieties, to bring fresh seeds of those that are poliembrionics? How long would a mango seed keep its germination capacity?

Why don't you pay for EMS?  About $45. I shipped mango scions from Florida to Phillipines and it took 5 days only.

Because of Customs, from USA to Spain EMS is 65€, if Customs agents see a small, very light packet and 65$ for shipping, they will most likely stop it and open it. That's the problem with scions.

Nothing is allowed technically, but I had a lot of EMS traffic seeds to US, few from from US,  quite a bit within SE Asia and nothing ever got confiscated. Sometimes you just have to be bold and count your lucky stars.
You could also send first to one of the relaxed EU countries up north if you have friends there and than forward within EU.  Those countries with relaxed customs and don't care about tropical stuff, it presents zero danger to them.

24
Short of unrelated questions in this thread. I sacrificed one of my Orange Sherbet to graft Sweet Tart on top. Didn't have rootstock around. Is there any way to extract propogatable material from the rootstock? As much as I like ST,  the better mango might be under.

25
I got a question for you guys. Given that shipping from USA can take up to 3 weeks and that Customs here is becoming more a more careful with vegetal stuff because of diseases like Xilella, purchasing scions is kind of a very risky bet for us. I've been said by another grower from Europe that rate of taking for imported scions from America is really low because of that. So I'm thinking now of another strategy to do it: Would be a safer, more successful way to get these new varieties, to bring fresh seeds of those that are poliembrionics? How long would a mango seed keep its germination capacity?

Why don't you pay for EMS?  About $45. I shipped mango scions from Florida to Phillipines and it took 5 days only.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 50
Copyright © Tropical Fruit Forum - International Tropical Fruit Growers