I look at all these video titles and they pretty much say the same thing: "This was the worst soil on the planet, and then overnight with my super magical green thumb, everything changed!
That pretty much sums it up. Add in a dash of flowery language...voila!
I haven't seen videos where they actually show detailed soil analysis to prove just how "bad" their soil was at the start. Nor is the viewer graced with the results of a third party audit to detail the inputs added or economics of the entire operation. I mean I could make a terrible soil great in a day, just give me a back hoe, rototiller and a few side-dump loads of lime and compost.
Here's an example of what I'm talking about:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cc3-3s115mMAnd a comment I read in its comment section that pretty much sums up my thoughts:
"Title is a little deceiving, that's not "desert sand", that area of Baja is quite fertile and local farmers have been growing vegetables there for decades. This isn't new at all, why do foreign people like to try to appropriate everything? Give due credit to the local guys who have been doing this for decades and pioneered these techniques."
I'm on this soapbox, because I know everyone's trying so hard to motivate others by making it look easy - like if you just take a PDC and listen to hippies talk about fairies then you can take a box of seeds and some builders clay and scatter seeds in the middle of the Sahara Desert, forests will pop out of nowhere, and the wildebeast will once again roam the ancient plains of the extinct Saharan prairie browsing tree Aloes to help ward off skin cancer. Nonetheless, everything is so much more nuanced than presented and there are situations where the same approach will be a disaster in someone else's neck of the woods.
My favorite ones are the ones where they plant thousands of trees and then "walk away" and come back a few years later, supposedly for the first time, with all sorts of camera gear, and ooh and ahh about how neat the new forest is, and brag about how only a few of the tree saplings have died. Congratulations, you have good soil. Go try that in most parts of the world on severely degraded, marginal, non-ag land and you might as well throw away money.