Hey TFF community, it's been a while since I've posted here. I wanted to share a recent video I made that might be useful for newer permaculture enthusiasts.
As many of you experienced growers already know, the "just add biology" approach often pushed in permaculture circles falls short without addressing mineral deficiencies. This reality became starkly apparent on our property in Peru, where we have two areas with identical management but dramatically different results due to underlying soil mineral content.
I documented this contrast in a video comparing the two sites, complete with ICP soil tests showing the total element levels. For many of you veterans, this information might seem obvious (I remember someone here once telling me "obviously you need to add nutrients over time if you're harvesting fruit"), but I've found this fundamental principle is often glossed over in permaculture education.
The video shows two areas of our farm about 100m apart - one thriving, one struggling - despite identical techniques. The ICP tests revealed the struggling area had only 128ppm total potassium in the topsoil.
Recently, when a permaculture instructor visited our property and suggested, "Mexican sunflower is successful at my place, and a lot of the syntropic people love it, have you considered using that plant to get more Potassium?" It was a perfect example of missing the point - you can't fix the absence of an element by simply planting an accumulator plant, right? Am I missing something here? Aren’t there laws of physics and stuff on this earth of ours? Even if Mexican sunflower were excellent at concentrating potassium, the plant can't perform alchemy - it needs to accumulate the potassium from somewhere, but our topsoil, subsoil, and parent materials are all extremely potassium deficient.
Fixing our deficiencies has been quite expensive, and I'm curious if any of you have found cost-effective solutions for large-scale remediation, particularly in tropical systems? Our conventional solution would be applying tons of wood ash, but the quantities needed make this challenging for our scale. Have used Potassium sulfate, but not sure how economically sustainable any of this is. You’d really need some high-priced value-added crops to compete with people growing in bottom-lands into the ashes of rainforests.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDTgyHAPykQ