I found a really good Honey Gold to be about equal to a Kensington Pride, but from memory it was a little less tangy and Fibrous.
R2E2 I hate. I hate the texture, and I hate the flavour. It's got zero tang and low sweetness.
Calypso is like a Kensington but inferior to it in every way. Less tang, less sweetness, less flavour - but it did have more colour - not that it really matters to a homegrower.
Keitt is nearly as good as Kensington, and has a similar flavour, and starts fruiting (commercially) as soon as Kensingtons start to come to an end.
I like that new 'Maha Bliss', and I reckon it is equal, if not a teeny bit better (hate to admit it!) than KP.
What do you do you think of any Florida selections that you have tasted, Gone Tropo? Has your orange sherbet fruited?
I find it really interesting finding out about the difference in Mango preferences between Aussies and Americans. At the end of the day, I want to try as many interesting mangoes as I can, and if I don't like them I can just top work them (and grow more varieties!).
And interesting point: Could the reason that there have been so many mango varieties bred and introduced in Florida be that when mangoes first went commercial, people were dissatisfied with the Tommy Atkins, and wanted better mangoes, and that desire to breed better mangoes never faded? Here in Australia, from my understanding KP was the first commercial mango, and from the start people loved. Why breed tonnes of new varieties when you have already found 'the best'?
Hey mate I personally prefer calypso, R2E2 and certainly honey gold over KP taste is of course subjective. My orange sherbert hasn't fruited yet and my lemon zest died. The people I know who have tried these zill varieties and compared with KP are people with large mango collections who know there mangoes well and I trust what they say. I will however come to my own conclusion once my own trees come into production.
Maha is excellent, I have tried most of the older florida varieties that are here and i dislike all of them they all have a chemical/turpentine aftertaste that our aussie mango's don't have. Our tastes seem to align much more with the SE asians.
[/quote]
My daughter says maha is a after dinner mango. As far as asian mangos, my wife likes Keow Savoy I personally would take a philippine over a Nam doc mai. Okrung Is over poweringly sweet. Ican only eat a little bit. Would like to try Tong Dam. This is one of my favorite trees. I'll like it better than orange sherbert.Po Pyu Kalay was introduced to Florida from Myanmar by Maurice Kong