1
Cold Hardy Citrus / Re: Experience with Ichangponsuma
« on: November 12, 2025, 03:19:18 PM »
I’ve heard and seen otherwise. The plants, especially in the northern german stock, still had Tintori labels on them. Those Tahizu from Tintori were then resold there as Yuzu.
It may be that Lubera is building up its own propagation, but that is currently not yet the case everywhere. Be that as it may, reselling is not a bad thing – it’s actually quite common. It only gets annoying when plants are sold under the wrong name, but that does happen.
My point is that Lubera has no first-hand experience with winter hardiness, cultivation and so on; they’ve simply copied this information.
And in my quick Google search I couldn’t find any minimum temperatures of -15 °C for IxPxS as stated by Lubera. It’s possible that someone reported this once, but without knowing the exact circumstances it’s quite bold to adopt such (maximum) figures when the general reports tend towards lower frost hardiness (in the sense of warmer degrees) . But Lubera is not alone in this either – Quissac is also at the very top when it comes to minimum temperature claims…
It may be that Lubera is building up its own propagation, but that is currently not yet the case everywhere. Be that as it may, reselling is not a bad thing – it’s actually quite common. It only gets annoying when plants are sold under the wrong name, but that does happen.
My point is that Lubera has no first-hand experience with winter hardiness, cultivation and so on; they’ve simply copied this information.
And in my quick Google search I couldn’t find any minimum temperatures of -15 °C for IxPxS as stated by Lubera. It’s possible that someone reported this once, but without knowing the exact circumstances it’s quite bold to adopt such (maximum) figures when the general reports tend towards lower frost hardiness (in the sense of warmer degrees) . But Lubera is not alone in this either – Quissac is also at the very top when it comes to minimum temperature claims…

