ANDERSON TROPICALS NEW YEAR SALE (Plinia martinellii)

[andersst]

NEW YEAR'S SALE STARTING AT 6 PM EST FRIDAY. USE "SALE15" AT CHECKOUT FOR 15% OFF!

WE WILL ALSO BE MAKING A VERY LIMITED QUANTITY OF PLINIA MARTINELLII AVAILABLE!



Click Here For Seeds Availability

[Mango Stein]

Do you mean Eugenia martinellii? https://powo.science.kew.org/results?q=Plinia%20martinellii

[Shovel n Seed]

I didn't see the plinia martinelli on the website

[andersst]

Do you mean Eugenia martinellii? https://powo.science.kew.org/results?q=Plinia%20martinellii

Frutas no Brazil refers to it as Plinia.

[andersst]

I didn't see the plinia martinelli on the website

To give everyone an equal opportunity they will go live at 6PM along with the sale.

[andersst]

SALE ENDS SUNDAY 1/8/2023 at 11:59 PM EST

[Mango Stein]

Do you mean Eugenia martinellii? https://powo.science.kew.org/results?q=Plinia%20martinellii

Frutas no Brazil refers to it as Plinia.

Aline Stadnik confirmed to me that both Frutas no Brasil and Flora do Brasil are incorrect. It's a Eugenia.

[Paraponera]

I really enjoy this resource.

http://www.worldfloraonline.org/taxon/wfo-0000278917#bibliography

https://www.nybg.org/science-project/world-flora-online/

It says that it is a Plinia.

Stirring the pot.

[Mango Stein]

I really enjoy this resource.

http://www.worldfloraonline.org/taxon/wfo-0000278917#bibliography

https://www.nybg.org/science-project/world-flora-online/

It says that it is a Plinia.

Stirring the pot.

What are you stirring? You are just regurgitating the same mistake using the same outdated source but on a different database. The Bibliography you linked to even says Stadnik, A., Flora Do Brasil, which I already pointed out is outdated. Half the time FdB doesn't even work. Sorry but Brazil is almost a third world country.

I have been communicating with Aline Stadnik over the last few years and she confirmed to me in private communication just yesterday that it is a Eugenia. She is the leading scientist on Brazilian Plinias and Eugenias, not to mention the very paper used in the bibliography for P. martinellii. You don't have to believe me but time will tell.

[Paraponera]

That is pretty cool. For me it is a bit of a stretch to believe just from visual comparisons of photographs alone. I haven't had the chance to speak with Aline Stadnik, but I'll take your word for it seeing as that is probably never going to happen. Lol

[andersst]

I really enjoy this resource.

http://www.worldfloraonline.org/taxon/wfo-0000278917#bibliography

https://www.nybg.org/science-project/world-flora-online/

It says that it is a Plinia.

Stirring the pot.

What are you stirring? You are just regurgitating the same mistake using the same outdated source but on a different database. The Bibliography you linked to even says Stadnik, A., Flora Do Brasil, which I already pointed out is outdated. Half the time FdB doesn't even work. Sorry but Brazil is almost a third world country.

I have been communicating with Aline Stadnik over the last few years and she confirmed to me in private communication just yesterday that it is a Eugenia. She is the leading scientist on Brazilian Plinias and Eugenias, not to mention the very paper used in the bibliography for P. martinellii. You don't have to believe me but time will tell.

Hey Mango,

Thank you for the info! We will do our research and will happily adjust with the proper scientific support. I agree there are many Plinia that have been categorized that are more likely Eugenia or Myrciaria.