Garcinia Identification

[Tropical Farmer]

Can anyone help with the identification of these various Garcinia plants please?

[tru]

2nd is maybe achacha or lucs?
3rd is lemondrop or brasiliensis
5th is achacha or lucs again, leaning toward lucs?

I'm not a very trained eye

[mikesid]

my guess:

1. Achachairuu
2. dulcis
3. mangostana
4. hombroniana?
5. brasiliensis

[tru]

I’m not sure how much of a help this may be because they are babies, but here are some pics for leaf comparison

sold to me as:
Achacha
brasiliensis
lemondrop

and luc’s from seed, I say luc’s for the 5th because the luc in this pic looked IDENTICAL to the top of the 5th one before mine started pushing a new leaf finally, used to be way more flat

[skhan]

my guess:

1. Achachairuu
2. dulcis
3. mangostana
4. hombroniana?
5. brasiliensis

1. Achachairuu (I agree)
2. dulcis (or xanthochymus, hard to tell)
3. mangostana (I think lucs)
4. hombroniana (I agree)
5. brasiliensis (or madruno)

[Tropical Farmer]

Thanks so much to everyone for all your help. I will continue to monitor the growth and hopefully, with fruiting in the future, I can confirm 100%.

Your help was greatly appreciated.
Jo

[Tropical Farmer]

Thanks to everyone that responded; your assistance is greatly appreciated.
Jo