We've had Pickering, Guava, Lemon Meringue, Dwarf Hawaiian, a Haden seedling, and Sugarloaf thus far.
Some Pickerings were bland, but others were at the top of their game with creamy texture and coconut undertones.
Lemon Meringues were amazing.
Guavas were good, but last year they were amazing.
Dwarf Hawaiian had a little Carrie undertone and were otherwise not memorable.
The Haden seedling was bland.
Sugarloaf was picked a little later than ideal, but we're really impressed with the pineapple and pina colada flavor.
Sugarloaf wins 2023 for us.

Second place goes to Lemon Meringue.